derisively-intellectual mets chatter

February 09, 2004

Pinch Me


I have no idea how I missed this, but thanks to Avkash at The Raindrops and Jeremy at Jeremy Heit's Blog for bringing it to my attention.

Mark Hale of the New York Post has written a refreshing article about Mike Cameron and what his defensive contributions will bring to the Mets. Now, many a sportswriter have written a thing or two about defense. Unfortunately, many a sportswriter have also written a thing or two about how good Derek Jeter is with the glove. Do you see where I'm going with this?

Much of today's baseball journalism relies much more on coverage than on analysis, which is fine for your average fan. The thinking fan, however, is less interested in regurgitated quotations and simple metrics (i.e. batting average and RBI) than the average fan. That's not to say that one is better than the other, but that sabermetrically-inclined individuals like myself yearn for more than the average newspaper article or Joe Morgan commentary can give us.

Thankfully, there is an abundance of great websites dedicated to such studies, helping to further the understanding of baseball. For a while, sabermetrics had its niche in old Bill James Abstracts, Rob Neyer columns, and websites like Baseball Primer and Baseball Prospectus.

Then, a number of mainstream writers at ESPN.com began mixing sabermetric staples into their articles and broadcasts. Most notably, Peter Gammons and Tim Kurkjian. Of course, some people still don't get it.

Despite the enlightenment of some folks at ESPN, local sportswriters, at least in the New York area, have remained old-school in their expression of statistics and performance. That is, until Mark Hale took it upon himself to bring everyone up to speed. Now, I've been known to rip Mark Hale in the past. However, he earns a big notch on his SABR belt for his article on Sunday.

Eschewing the traditional, anecdotal defensive evaluatories like "he has a great arm" and "I know what I see", and even less complex defensive metrics like zone rating and range factor, Hale dives right into Mitchel Lichtman's (aka MGL) UZR (Ultimate Zone Rating). Check out this article and this article for a detailed explanation of Lichtman's methodologies.

While some sabermetric tools (like OPS) have found their way onto the airwaves of ESPN and even onto the backs of Topps cards, Mark Hale has taken a huge step forward by writing an actual article featuring something as bold as UZR. I commend Mark and the Post for taking this leap of faith, and I can only hope that the response is positive and that this inspires other writers to include more advanced metrics in their work.


Comments

actually, sportswriters tended to write on derek jeter's "intangibles" and his "leadership," along with his athletic plays; more recently, they've had to defend his questionable glovesmanship and crappy range on routine plays with that same routine. mike cameron tangibly covers half the field and allows corner fielders and managers and pitchers breathe a little easier...

Posted by: pico - February 10, 2004 at 11:09 AM EST

SABERMETS INFO







SPONSORS


what's this?
CALENDAR

August 2005
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      
SEARCH

BOOKS

Currently Reading:

Rob Bradford: Chasing Steinbrenner
Chasing Steinbrenner
Rob Bradford

Jeff Pearlman: The Bad Guys Won
The Bad Guys Won
Jeff Pearlman

Baseball Prospectus 2004
Baseball Prospectus 2004


Lawrence S. Ritter: The Glory of Their Times
The Glory of Their Times
Lawrence S. Ritter

On Deck:

Bill James: Whatever Happened to the Hall of Fame
Whatever Happened to the Hall of Fame
Bill James

Just Finished:

Jim Bouton: Ball Four
Ball Four
Jim Bouton

Pete Rose: My Prison Without Bars
My Prison Without Bars
Pete Rose
METS NEWS

ARCHIVES

RECENT ENTRIES

RECENT COMMENTS

Slammin' Sammy at Shea (9)
Peter wrote: Stanton is on the Yankees...What th...[more]

Spring Training Open Thread (5)
John E wrote: I agree with the injury concerns an...[more]

This Is Me Talking (5)
a2d wrote: I think we all came off well. I was...[more]

Bloggy McBloggerson (2)
bronxmetfan wrote: What is going on with Ayer Soler (t...[more]

Mientkiewicz or Lee (8)
m2c2c2 wrote: This was my least favorite move of ...[more]

METS INFO

METS IN PRINT

METS BLOGS

OTHER BASEBALL BLOGS

BASEBALL WEBSITES

BASEBALL COLUMNISTS

MLB PLAYER INDEX

TOOLS FOR FOOLS

REQUIRED READING

Goodbye To Some Old Baseball Ideas
Branch Rickey

Pitching And Defense
Voros McCracken

Pitching And Defense
Tom Tippett

The Sabermetric Manifesto
David Grabiner

Transaction Primer
Rob Neyer

Rule V Draft Explanation
Baseball America

... in progress ...
CREDITS

Powered by
Movable Type 2.661

Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.